60,000Bq/L… Not Great, Not Terrible

Wow, this just popped out of the blue. Japan’s environmental minister stated in a press release that Tokyo Electric Power(TEPco) will have to dump Fukushima nuclear powerplant’s radioactive wastewater into the ocean for dilution as it runs out of storage space (one of the many articles). Well doesn’t that sound like the plot to 2014’s Godzilla!

Irradiated sea monsters aside, there are serious controversies and environmental implications of this decision. The Korean government and Japanese fishermen are quite understandably vocal about their concerns with this decision (McCurry, 2019). Meanwhile, Osaka offers to dump radioactive wastewater into Osaka bay as long as it only contains tritium and is environmentally safe (Johnston, 2019).

What’s the big issue with dumping radioactive wastewater? Radionuclides! Specifically, Caesium-134(134Cs), Caesium-137(137Cs), Strontium-90(90Sr), and Tritium(3H), the most prevalent nuclear fallout products at Fukushima now(TEPco, 2019). These radionuclides emit high-energy particles when they decay, which literally tears up DNA upon contact. This causes cells to reproduce into defunct and cancerous cells or even cell death(S. Dingwall, C.E. Mills, N. Phan, K. Taylor, 2011; Starr; Taggart; Evers; Starr, 2019).
Water treatment at Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant involves treating the water used to cool the damaged fuel rods in Reactors 1, 2, and 3. The main processes are:

  1. Ion-exchange modules (Kurion/Sarry) that exchange strontium and caesium ions for less harmful ones.
  2. Reverse osmosis (RO) that recycles clean water into the reactor core and concentrates remaining brine
  3. Adsorption of remaining caesium, strontium and other (heavy) metals onto various substrates

“Multi-nuclide removal equipment” for process 3. Source: https://www7.tepco.co.jp/wp-content/uploads/hd03-02-03-001-m120625_01-e.pdf

Now you might have noticed that there is a radionuclide I listed earlier that is missing from the treatment process above. That’s right, it’s tritium! Being an isotope of hydrogen, it is incorporated into a H2O molecule as HTO, and passes seamlessly through all of the processes above just like plain old water. Yet, HTO is as dangerous as any radionuclide when tritium decays. What’s worse, TEPco has 800,000m3 of tritiated water sitting around with no feasible isotopic separation method (METI, 2016).

Fortunately, tritium ionizing radiation possesses very little energy and is unable to pass through physical environments or even the layer of dead skin on your epidermis. Contamination is therefore primarily through ingestion or inhalation of tritiated molecules. Dingwall et al. (2011) referred to Brooks et al. (1976) that found that mice could receive 37,000,000 Bq/L of tritiated water without damaging their DNA and causing adverse health effects.

The Tritiated Water Task Force of TEPco estimates a tritiated water concentration of 0.3 to 3.3million Bq/L as of March 2016. They plan to dilute the tritiated water with seawater until concentration levels are 60,000Bq/L before discharge. They also estimate this concentration to drop by 3 orders of magnitude 100km away from the point of discharge (ie.a maximum of 60 Bq/L). To provide perspective, this exceeds most standards of tritium in drinking water.

 

With all the bad press surrounding Japan, we need to recognise that environments close to the source of discharge face potentially unknown effects of concentrated tritiated water (IRSN, 2012); as well as acknowledge what they have accomplished to reduce impacts as much as they have. Less fear-mongering, more research!

References:

^Back to the Top^

Brooks, A. L., Carsten, A. L., Mead, D. K., Retherford, J. C., & Crain, C. R. (1976). The Effect of Continuous Intake of Tritiated Water (HTO) on the Liver Chromosomes of Mice. Radiation Research. https://doi.org/10.2307/3574329

Cecie Starr; Ralph Taggart; Christine Evers; Lisa Starr. (2019). Biology: The Unity and Diversity of Life, 15th Edition. Retrieved from https://www.cengage.com/c/biology-the-unity-and-diversity-of-life-15e-starr/

Dingwall, S., Mills, C. E., Phan, N., Taylor, K., & Boreham, D. R. (2011). Human health and the biological effects of tritium in drinking water: Prudent policy through science – Addressing the ODWAC new recommendation. Dose-Response. https://doi.org/10.2203/dose-response.10-048.Boreham

E. Johnston (2019). Osaka mayor Ichiro Matsui offers to take in tainted Fukushima water and dump it into Osaka Bay. Japan Times. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2019/09/17/national/osaka-mayor-offers-take-tainted-fukushima-water-dump-osaka-bay/#.XYMScCgzZEY

IRSN (2012) Radionuclide sheet: Tritium and the environment. Institut de radioprotection et de sûreté nucléaire. https://www.irsn.fr/EN/Research/publications-documentation/radionuclides-sheets/environment/Pages/Tritium-environment.aspx

J. McCurry (2019). Fukushima: Japan will have to dump radioactive water into Pacific, minister says. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/sep/10/fukushima-japan-will-have-to-dump-radioactive-water-into-pacific-minister-says

METI (2016).Tritiated Water Task Force Report, June 2016. Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry https://www.meti.go.jp/english/earthquake/nuclear/decommissioning/pdf/20160915_01a.pdf

Appendix:

Radionuclide concentrations around reactor sites(pardon my underlining skills)
Source for Table: https://www4.tepco.co.jp/decommission/data/analysis/pdf_csv/2019/3q/2tb-east_19091301-j.pdf
Source for sampling sites around the reactors: https://www4.tepco.co.jp/en/nu/fukushima-np/f1/smp/form_pdf/2tb-east_form-e.pdf

 

130 thoughts on “60,000Bq/L… Not Great, Not Terrible

  1. A network design is an illustration or plan that shows how a computer or telecommunication network works. It depicts the many elements that make up a system, as well as how they communicate, such as routers, devices, hubs, and firewalls. A network diagram may contain a lot of information or only offer a general overview, according to its original mission. A LAN diagram, for example, may indicate individual computer IP addresses, but a MAN (metropolitan area network) diagram may depict buildings or regions with a single node.

  2. If you want to pay someone to take your online class, Myclassprofessor is the best website. It is a USA based company offering online academic help to students across United State. We complete assignments for students who are either busy or fed up to do it themselves. Our clients include students from some of the best universities in USA. They select us because we guarantee good grades and timely delivery.

  3. There are online classes acceptable for any profession. As a result, we are ready to assist you immediately. We promise high numbers of points and goals for all your actions related to Climate Change and Wildfires. Our group of experts is ready and waiting to work with you around the clock. We offer a 100% cash-back guarantee if you are not comfortable with our work.

  4. game Macau, Keluaran Macau, Data Macau, Pengeluaran Macau Hari Ini

    game cambodia atau game cambodia merupakan taruhan menebak nomor jitu dari game hari ini. Seluruh informasi dan juga fasilitas yang disediakan oleh game cambodia bisa dengan mudahnya dilihat melalui halaman keluaran cambodia tercepat dan pengeluaran cambodia hari ini. Seluruh live result cambodia yang ditampilkan nantinya akan langsung disimpan kedalam tabel data cambodia lengkap. Informasi game cambodia sendiri menjadi sebuah pelayanan yang paling banyak dicari di Indonesia. Tentu hal ini menandakan, bahwa taruhan nomor game cambodia sendiri memang sudah sangat terkenal

  5. The decision to dump radioactive wastewater from Fukushima into the ocean raises serious concerns about environmental impact and public health. Radionuclides like Caesium-134, Caesium-137, Strontium-90, and Tritium pose significant risks, including DNA damage and cancerous cell growth. I have been working at buddy assignment help since 2019. As per my knowledge, while water treatment processes aim to mitigate these risks, the long-term effects remain uncertain. The controversy underscores the need for transparent communication and responsible environmental management.

  6. Trity Environ Solutions is the go-to choice for businesses seeking a reliable and efficient Sewage Treatment Plant Manufacturer in Dehradun . With their expertise and cutting-edge technology, they have established themselves as leaders in the industry. When it comes to wastewater management, their solutions are top-notch and environmentally friendly. If you’re in need of a trusted partner for your wastewater treatment needs, Trity Environ Solutions is the name to remember. Contact them today to explore how they can tailor a solution to meet your specific requirements.

  7. Wonderful day! I’m glad to have you here. The solution for students looking for explanations for their Take my online class is the AllAssignmentSupport service. We’ve got you covered, whether you’re handling essays or complicated projects. Say goodbye to academic pretense and accept success with joy.

  8. What recent decision regarding the Fukushima nuclear power plant’s radioactive wastewater was announced by Japan’s environmental minister, and what comparison does the situation evoke?
    telkom university

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *