FASS Research Gallery
Department of Political Science
Making Identity Count: Building a National Identity Database (2016)
Edited by Ted Hopf and Bentley B. Allan
Oxford University Press
Constructivism, despite being one of the three main streams of IR theory, along with realism and liberalism, is rarely, if ever, tested in large-n quantitative work. Constructivists almost unanimously eschew quantitative approaches, assuming that variables of interest to constructivists, defy quantification. Quantitative scholars mostly ignore constructivist variables as too fuzzy and vague. And the rare instances in which quantitative scholars have operationalized identity as a variable, they have unfortunately realized all the constructivists’ worst fears about reducing national identity to a single measure, such as language, religion, or ethnicity, thereby violating one of the foundational assumptions of constructivism: intersubjectivity.
Making Identity Count presents a new method for the recovery of national identity, applies the method in 9 country cases, and draws conclusions from the empirical evidence for hegemonic transitions and a variety of quantitative theories of identity. Ted Hopf and Bentley B. Allan make the constructivist variable of national identity a valid measure that can be used by large-n International Relations scholars in a variety of ways. They lay out what is wrong with how identity has been conceptualized, operationalized and measured in quantitative IR so far and specify a methodological approach that allows scholars to recover the predominant national identities of states in a more valid and systematic fashion. The book includes “national identity reports” on China, the US, UK, Germany, France, Brazil, Japan, and India to both test the authors’ method and demonstrate the promise of the approach. Hopf and Allan use these data to test a constructivist hypothesis about the future of Western neoliberal democratic hegemony. Finally, the book concludes with an assessment of the method, including areas of possible improvement, as well as a description of what an intersubjective national identity data base of great powers from 1810-2010 could mean for IR scholarship.
Access the project website.
The following Political Science students also contributed as chapter writers:
- “Development’ as a means to an unknown end: Chinese National Identity in 2010”
- Liang Ce (Class of 2014 and current PS post-graduate student)
- Rachel Zeng Rui (PS post-graduate student)
- “Whither La France? French National Identity in 2010”
- Benjamin Chan Jian Ming (Class of 2014)
- Rebecca Oh Sin May (Class of 2014)
- “The Politics of Responsibility: Germany National Identity in 2010”
- Lim Kaiheng (Class of 2015)