Apr 15th, 2009
Hyena Dominance, A Product of Nature or Nurture?
The Hyena is a mammalian family of order Carnivora. Hyenas are native to both African and Asian continents. They consist of four living species, the Striped Hyena and Brown Hyena (genus Hyaena), the Spotted Hyena (genus Crocuta), and the Aardwolf (genus Proteles). Hyenas generally live in packs which are led by a matriarch. In hyena society, the females are the dominant gender. This trait is shared by all four sub-species. The spotted hyena goes one step further, with females being larger in size than males. This article, by analyzing two studies on hyenas, aims to show that both nature and nurture play important roles in contributing to this unique gender dominance in spotted hyena society.
In a study which made it to the international science journal Nature, Michigan State University zoology professor Kay Holekamp, her former graduate student Stephanie Dloniak and Jeffrey French from the University of Nebraska, reported that high-ranking, dominant spotted hyena mothers pass to their offspring high levels of certain hormones that make cubs more aggressive and sexually vigorous.[1] This allowed cubs to have a better chance of surviving to adulthood and reproducing. The study found higher levels of androgen during the final stages of pregnancy in the more dominant females as compared to the lower-ranking group members.[2] These hormones played a significant influence on the behaviour and appearance of the offspring. “What this means is that there are gifts a mom can give to her baby. She can manipulate her offspring’s behaviour and help her kids to survive and reproduce successfully by transferring status-related traits via prenatal hormone exposure,” said Holekamp.[3] In addition, the maculinizing effects of androgens causes females to gain greater muscle mass, aggressive behaviour and dominance. More aggressive females are better able to compete for food when hyenas squabble over kills.[4] This study supports the nature theory.
The second study published in the scientific journal Behavioral Ecology suggests that dominance is more a case of nurture, and that hyenas inherit their social status. An international team of scientists from the Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW) in Berlin, Germany, and the University of Sheffield, UK, used observations during the last 20 years of rare cases of adoption among hyenas in the Serengeti and Ngorongoro Crater in Tanzania in combination with the latest molecular techniques to identify genetic mothers to demonstrate that hyena mothers pass on their social status by supporting their young during social interactions with other group members.[5] In spotted hyena society, social status is highly important. It determines access to resources, survival and reproductive success. As a result, parents may attempt to pass on their status to their offspring. “In spotted hyenas, surrogate mothers adopt young cubs soon after their birth. The adopted cubs obtained a rank at adulthood that was similar to and just below the rank of their surrogate mother. In contrast, the rank of adopted offspring was unrelated to the rank of their genetic mother” says Dr Marion East from the IZW. “This is consistent with the idea that maternal behavioural support determines rank inheritance.”[6]
The results of the second study however throw into doubt two existing hypotheses explaining dominance in spotted hyenas. The first being that mothers might transfer genes that cause their offspring to be as competitive as themselves; and the second being, maternal status might determine the concentration of maternal androgens that a foetus is exposed to, and this exposure in turn might make offspring become as competitive as their mother. “These hypotheses would predict a relationship between the rank of adopted offspring and that of their genetic mother, but we found no evidence of such a relationship” explains Dr Oliver Höner from the IZW.[7] The study suggests that hyena young learn as they grow which group members they can dominate when their mother helps them win contests against group members that are subordinate to the mother. As they grow older and reach adulthood, they continue to defend the privilege passed down to them.[8]
To conclude, it is my believe that it is impossible to split the cause of hyena dominance to either simply nature, or nurture alone. They both play apart in contributing to hyena dominance. Perhaps maybe more so in hyena society as compared to any other species, hyenas need the heavy mixture of both nature and nurture to attain their aggressiveness and dominance to continue surviving and reproducing.
[1] Michigan State University (2006, April 27). Hyena Mothers Give Their Cubs A Helpful Dose Of Hormones. ScienceDaily. Retrieved April 15, 2009, from http://www.sciencedaily.com /releases/2006/04/060426173221.htm
[2] Ibid.
[3] Ibid.
[4] Ibid.
[5] Forschungsverbund Berlin e.V. (FVB) (2009, March 7). How Hyenas ‘Inherit’ Their Social Status. ScienceDaily. Retrieved April 15, 2009, from http://www.sciencedaily.com /releases/2009/02/090225073209.htm
[6] Ibid.
[7] Ibid.
[8] Ibid.






